A funeral, a ghost, a murder. It's all in a day's work for Emma Lee Raines … especially when the ghost turns out to be someone very dear to her heart.

Psychic Debbie Dually is the one who informed local undertaker Emma Lee Raines that she wasn't crazy, she was a Betweener, someone who can communicate with ghosts of the not-so-dearly departed. In fact, she told Emma Lee how she was the only one that could help solve their murders to help them rest in eternal peace.

This time Debbie Dually finds herself needing Emma's help. This means solving her own murder.

Emma goes deep undercover as a fake psychic in order to see into the past and help Debbie cross over. Emma Lee doesn't realize this opens up a whole can of new Betweener clients that refuse to leave her alone.

When Emma Lee is tagged as the number one suspect in Debbie Dually's death, her handsome state trooper boyfriend, Jack Henry, has no choice but to come back to Sleepy Hollow and get to the bottom of what is going on before it's too late and Emma Lee goes to the state pen for a very long time.